Tlaib’s latest anti-Semitic invective continues bad trend – Guest Contributor Ari Kaufman

288 Views
On the heels of Rep. Ilhan Omar’s multiple anti-Semitic smears I’ve written about, a fellow freshman congresswoman in the Midwest continues the bad habit. 

An old rule of debate is the first person to use a Holocaust analogy loses. Perhaps Democrat Rep. Rashida Tlaib (MI) never learned this rule.

Less than a week after Holocaust Remembrance Day, she commented, among other things during a fawning left-leaning Yahoo podcast entitled “From Rashida With Love,” that thinking about the Holocaust gives her a “calming feeling.”

A BDS supporter, Tlaib went on to say that her Palestinian ancestors were impacted by the Holocaust’s aftermath, all while defending the one-state solution to theoretically resolve tensions between Palestinians and Israelis.
{It should be noted that the “one state solution” is an absurd, deadly policy supported only by extremists like Hamas terrorists. It effectively means the eradication of Israel, the first and only home of world Jewry after thousands of years of persecution. That is a genocidal policy supported by a U.S. politician.}
After her horrific rhetoric Tlaib, like Omar, conveniently played the victim and predictably engaged in straw man attacks, writing in part on Twitter: “Policing my words, twisting & turning them to ignite vile attacks on me will not work. All of you who are trying to silence me will fail miserably…it was my ancestors — Palestinians — who lost their land and some lost their lives, their livelihood, their human dignity, their existence in many ways…”
Rashida Tlaib is a public figure, and like any politician, we will carefully listen to and closely analyze her words. No one wants to silence her. She knows this and her feckless comments do her a disservice. 
As to the substance, her claims are simply inaccurate. Palestinians did not “lose” anything after World War II. 
Once liberated concentration camp survivors left the nightmare of war-ravaged Europe, many of these Jews journeyed to their Biblical homeland of Israel to reunite with long-lost family and friends. Rather than greeting them, as Tlaib’s revisionism would have us believe, Arabs quickly rioted and convinced the compliant British to halt Jewish immigration. 
As soon as Israel finally and legally became a state in 1948, Arab countries quickly declared war on the new nation. They fought, and Israel miraculously prevailed. Since then, Palestinians could’ve had their own state many times, yet their belligerent leaders always refused, since the ultimate goal is the destruction of Israel, not peace. 
Jews were also in the Holy Land at least a thousand years before Arabs existed and constituted the majority in sparsely-populated Jerusalem since the early 19th century, as well as a clear majority along the Mediterranean coast since the 1910s. Arabs were a very small group in an area basically destroyed by the Romans 2,000 years before. 
And were regional Arab leaders three generations ago philo-Semitic, as Tlaib may have us believe? No, the precise opposite is true.
Haj Amin al-Hussein, the Grand Mufti of Jerusalem (Muslim leader of Palestine during the Second World War), infamously met with Adolf Hitler late in 1941, where he thanked the Fuhrer for the “great honor he had bestowed” by receiving him. He also conveyed thanks, sympathy and “admiration from the entire Arab world” for support Hitler had shown in public speeches for the Arab and “especially the Palestinian cause.”
Indeed the Mufti sought a “Final Solution of the Jewish Question” just as much as the Nazis did.
Whether in America or Europe, open season for Jew hatred seemingly continues. Speaker Nancy Pelosi and Democrat leadership inexplicably missed an easy opportunity in March for a resolution specifically condemning anti Semitism after Omar’s dangerous bigotry. 
Until repercussions for repugnant, hurtful comments by left-wing politicians occurs, we are unfortunately likely to see more of this disgraceful, vile rhetoric, including violence like last month at the San Diego synagogue.

A California native, former school teacher and military historian, Ari Kaufman has worked as a journalist for various publications around the country since 2004. He lives with his wife in Minnesota.

Omar’s shameful, anti-Semitic rhetoric deserves unequivocal condemnation

347 Views

Guest Opinion by Ari Kaufman

I’ve sadly lost count of the anti-Semitic smears coming from Rep. Ilhan Omar (D-MN) since she took her U.S. congressional seat just two months ago. This bigotry deserves broad condemnation with punitive actions behind it.

Ironically, Omar was easily elected with the support of many Jewish voters in the most heavily-Jewish area of Minnesota. Despite past examples to the contrary, I am certain many in the 5th congressional District — where she received nearly 80% of the vote last November —  had hopes for her to be a unifying and effective politician. To say she’s failed on that matter during her first two months in Washington would be a massive understatement.During her campaign, Omar apparently assured local Jewish groups, including the Minnesota Jewish Community Relations Council, that her past egregious comments on Israel and Judaism wouldn’t be an issue or arise again; yet here we are, with another insult and anti-Semitic statement seemingly occurring every week.

As a Jew happily residing in the Land of 10,000 Lakes, I put America first and surely do not have “dual loyalty” to Israel and the USA — as Omar and others like freshman representative and fellow Muslim Rashida Tlaib (D-MI) have accused some —  nor does my wife, nor do my Jewish family members and friends.

In her initial half-hearted apology on Feb. 11, Omar, at the tender age of 37, said she’s “listening and learning,” yet she’s since quickly doubled and tripled down on anti-Semitic canards and other insidious rhetoric.

Unsurprisingly, the congresswoman also has her facts completely wrong on Israel, which undermines the USA’s long-standing support toward our chief and only true Middle East ally.

Criticizing American support for the only Jewish country in a region, surrounded by substantially-larger Muslim nations (Iran, Iraq, Lebanon, Syria, et al.) sworn to Israel’s literal destruction for generations, makes such criticism suspect.

Christians, Jews, Americans and freedom lovers everywhere support Israel, Ms. Omar, because the nation is rooted in Judeo-Christian values; offers free and fair elections; vast contributions to defense, technology, medicine and science; and perhaps most importantly, as a military ally and the lone democracy in a region of autocratic regimes, enemies of Israel hate the United States as well.

While I was initially pleased to see Democrat leadership finally introduce an anti-Semitism resolution earlier this week, now I am dismayed.
First, the “resolution” was delayed, then, due to blowback from the increasingly anti-Semitic progressive wing, it was tweaked into a clumsy, Kindergarten-level “anti-hate Bill” to “confront the reality of anti-Semitism, Islamophobia, racism and other forms of bigotry” with Omar’s name not even mentioned; though it passed easily, the bill became too broad, lost its teeth and overall purpose. This is all fatuous, to put it mildly.
Meanwhile, far left Democrats, many in the Congressional Black Caucus, and much of the media, along with dozens of Twin Cities politicians and national Muslim groups, are now staging fundraising events in support of Omar’s bigotry.

An easy and necessary step would be the removal of the unapologetic Omar — who has never visited Israel yet supports the viciously anti-Semitic BDS movement — from the powerful Foreign Affairs Committee, where she currently sits. More than a dozen Jewish groups of various political stripes, including the venerable and left-leaning Anti-Defamation League, recently asked Speaker Pelosi to do this. She has not and undoubtedly will not. The speaker continues to kowtow to young, naive radicals in her party, especially those “of color”.

Conversely, when Rep. Steve King (R-IA) made controversial racial remarks in January, he immediately offered an apology, while the Republican Party swiftly removed him from all committee assignments, yet no action has been taken by Democrats against Omar. Why not? Ilhan Omar is the quintessential definition of an anti Semite.

On a local level, I also hope for further condemnation of this bigotry from Minnesota’s Democrat Sens. Amy Klobuchar, Tina Smith, the rest of the state’s congressional delegation, and Minnesota Gov. Tim Walz. I surely don’t expect to hear from Omar’s congressional predecessor and current Minnesota Attorney General Keith Ellison, who has his own troubling history of anti-Semitic associations and invective.

So far there is simple silence, or unfathomable agreement with such hate from fellow radical leftists like Reps. Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez (D-NY), Pramila Jayapal (D-WA) and the execrable Sen. Bernie Sanders (D-VT.), a leading 2020 Democrat presidential candidate.

Concurrence with anti-Semitic bigotry is not an option; turning the American Democrat Party into Jeremy Corbyn’s British Labour Party of Jewish hatred is not either, I’d hope. Continuous denouncements of vile, ignorant statements, however, are vital to our free republic.

**

https://www.weeklystandard.com/scott-w-johnson/the-anti-israel-seat

https://www.twincities.com/2019/03/01/ilhan-omar-went-on-a-fence-mending-tour-with-local-jews-then-she-offended-them-again/

https://pjmedia.com/trending/the-morning-briefing-omar-antisemitism-resolution-put-on-hold-and-much-much-more/

https://www.usatoday.com/story/opinion/2019/03/06/ilhan-omars-comments-were-anti-semitic-rhetoric-says-adl-talker/3078821002/

https://www.commentarymagazine.com/anti-semitism/dont-believe-ilhan-omar/

https://pjmedia.com/trending/facing-lawsuit-rep-ilhan-omar-deletes-tweet-smearing-covington-catholic-boys/

A California native, and former school teacher and military historian, Ari Kaufman has worked as a journalist for various publications around the country since 2004. He lives with his wife in Minnesota.